Traditionally the most popular roofing material, asphalt shingles are less expensive than metal roofing, both because of the material and the installation. As a result, Remodeling magazine indicates that it can expect to recover 61.2% of the cost of installing metal roofs and 65.9% for roof tiles. As consumer education increases, metal roofs continue to gain market share every year, while tile roofs continue to lose market share every year. Consequently, as consumer awareness and buying habits move away from shingles to metal, homeowners reasonably expect a metal roof to increase the value of their home.
Corrugated metal panels (such as our ABM panel) often cost up to 20% less per square than asphalt shingles. However, before you get too excited, remember that a metal roof requires more accessories, such as screws, flashings, and ridge caps. With the included fixtures, a metal roof can cost about the same as a tile roof in an average home, or within a few hundred dollars. And considering that our premium and standard metal panels come with 40-year paint warranties (with many metal roofs even lasting more than 100 years with proper maintenance), the savings over time makes metal a smarter choice.
Asphalt tile roof is a dominant material for residences. However, metal roofs are gaining in popularity as more aesthetic options become available. Now, there are metal tiles and panels that imitate materials such as slate, tile, beaten wood and even asphalt. Metal is lightweight, energy efficient and durable.
It comes in a variety of formats and designs, including shingles, stand-up seam, wood shake and tile. This makes it a versatile and attractive product. The following guide addresses the advantages and disadvantages of metal roofing in general (rather than particular subtypes) compared to three-tab asphalt shingles. This chart outlines the best options for the main considerations and uses.
Mosaic and composite are two other options to consider for this project. The composite is comparable to the price of architectural asphalt shingles, where the tile is comparable to metal. Tile is renewable and energy efficient like metal. Both will require less maintenance and will last longer than asphalt.
The chart below outlines how each compares in important areas of concern. In most cases, roof and metal installation are more expensive than. However, there are expensive architectural shingles that cost more than lower-cost metals, such as aluminum. You can usually install metal roofing over shingles because most types are lightweight, thin, and flexible.
However, it is best to consult with a professional about your situation. Want to make sure the roof and shingles are in proper shape for the project. Can a new metal roof be installed over an old one? What kind of service and paint will a rusty metal roof need?. In contrast, metal roof systems are inherently less prone to damage from Mother Nature because they are designed to withstand high winds.
The truth is that the roofing contractor you hire has the most impact on all aspects of your roofing project. But metal roofs in zinc, aluminum, galvanized metals, and even copper, in addition to tin, have come a long way from the farm. In general, metal roofs cost more in initial construction (and significantly more in certain cases), but they also tend to require less maintenance. We can now apply the same premise to metal roofing panels with a better understanding of lifecycle costs.
According to recent data, metal roofs now hold 12% of remodeling market share and 8% of spending on new residential construction. There is practically no room to make mistakes, so the metal roof must be installed by a trained craftsman. The Asphalt Roofing Manufacturers Association states on its website: “If a residential roof is more than 20 years old, it is a prime candidate for re-roofing. In addition to the variety of color options, these paint systems are extensively tested in a real outdoor environment to ensure they can last for decades, so reliable metal roofs are backed by paint guarantees.
Many metal coil and sheet manufacturers now offer cold roofs, which are highly emissive metal panels that release absorbed heat at higher temperatures and retain heat in cooler temperatures. The higher the work, the lower the material price per square foot, especially for standing seam metal roofs. Metal roof colors that meet the Energy Star approved minimum solar reflectance index (SRI) rating of 25, meaning that at least 25% of the sun's energy was reflected in the atmosphere, qualify for a special energy efficiency tax credit. Shingles are usually nailed to wood-framed roof structures, laid in layers, and staggered upwards from the lowest point of a pitched roof.